spine ·Level of evidence: Randomized trial
Is Biportal Endoscopic Laminectomy Equivalent to Microscopic Laminectomy in Patients With Lumbar Spinal Stenosis? A Multicenter, Assessor-blind, Randomized Clinical Trial
Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research (CORR)
Scientific core
A multicenter, assessor-blind randomized clinical trial in South Korea assigned 120 adults with lumbar spinal stenosis to biportal endoscopic laminectomy (n=60) or microscopic laminectomy (n=60). The primary endpoint was Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) at 12 months, tested for equivalence within a ±12.8-point margin (MCID). Modified intention-to-treat analysis showed mean ODI 13±12 versus 18±18 (mean difference −5; 95% CI −10 to 1; p=0.12), meeting equivalence. Secondary pain, quality-of-life, and adverse-event results were broadly comparable. Authors caution that theoretical soft-tissue advantages of endoscopy did not yield clinically meaningful patient-perceived superiority at one year, tempering uncritical wide adoption until stronger outcome advantages appear. Related 2024 Bayesian network meta-analysis of posterior decompression techniques and a 2025/26 meta-analysis of minimally invasive tubular versus open decompression similarly stress technique trade-offs with often comparable patient-reported function. Laminectomy removes lamina bone to decompress nerves; choice among open, tubular, microscopic, or biportal endoscopic routes should rest on evidence, anatomy, and surgical expertise rather than assumed superiority.
This assessor-blind multicenter RCT supports statistical equivalence of biportal endoscopic and microscopic laminectomy on 12-month ODI for lumbar stenosis within a predefined MCID-based margin. Secondary PROMs and adverse events were broadly similar, so technique selection may reasonably prioritize surgeon proficiency, visualization preference, and resource availability rather than expected large functional gaps. Theoretical soft-tissue benefits of endoscopy did not translate into superior patient-reported outcomes at one year; integrate these data with recent network and tubular-versus-open meta-analyses when teaching indications and shared decision-making.
In this study of 120 people with lumbar spinal stenosis, biportal endoscopic laminectomy and microscopic laminectomy led to similar improvements in day-to-day function after one year. Pain, quality-of-life, and safety findings were also broadly alike; the study did not show one method clearly better for how patients feel. Your surgeon can explain which approach suits your spine anatomy and overall health—results differ from person to person.
At Faraz Hospital Bahawalpur, neurosurgery counselling can review laminectomy options and realistic one-year expectations using current comparative evidence.
Featured image: AI-generated conceptual editorial image – not from the cited study / not a clinical photograph. تصویر: مصنوعی ذہانت سے تیار کردہ تصویری اداریہ — حوالہ شدہ تحقیق سے نہیں / کلینیکل فوٹو نہیں۔
Educational digest only — not personal medical advice, not a diagnosis, and not a treatment recommendation. Discuss decisions with your treating clinician. یہ صرف تعلیمی خلاصہ ہے — ذاتی طبی مشورہ، تشخیص یا علاج کی سفارش نہیں۔ فیصلے اپنے معالج سے کریں۔
AI WhatsApp: 0300 087 4232 — booking & PA assistant
AI booking & PA assistant — appointments and a brief note on lab reports. Does not diagnose. Does not interpret imaging for patients. Emergencies escalate to the doctor. AI limits & privacy
Emergency — direct Dr Wasif: 0345 825 4232 (not for routine booking)